Returning Production Is the Sharpest Edge in August — Here’s Who Has It
- Brandon Uhlmeyer
- Aug 6
- 5 min read
Intro
Returning production is a weird stat. Let’s be honest — it only really matters sometimes. If a wagon like Clemson brings back 80% of their starters, it’s game-changing. But if Southern Miss trots out 86% of a team that went 1–11, who cares?
That’s the trap most bettors fall into. They look at returning production and assume it guarantees a similar season. But here's the truth: when you're flying blind early in the season, returning production is one of the few real edges we have. Especially before transfers gel and new schemes click.
How many times have we seen a transfer-loaded top-10 team come out of the gate slow — then suddenly “figure it out” in Week 3? That early-season cohesion matters. And teams that didn’t gut their roster for shiny portal toys? They’ve got something even more valuable: chemistry.
It’s rarely talked about. But I believe it’s the most overlooked X-factor in early-season college football. So with that said, here are the Top 5 teams returning the most production heading into the 2025 season — and why that matters more than you think.
The Top 5 Teams Returning the MOST Production
Clemson Tigers - 81%
I didn’t just bring up Clemson as a clever example — this team is absolutely fucking stacked because everyone stayed. They brought in just four new guys this year. Four. So what’s Dabo trying to tell us?
Well, you dumbass, he’s telling us he thinks this is the team. The one that’s going to win it all.
Sure, Dabo’s always been stubborn about the transfer portal. But this year? It’s different. Not because he changed — but because he didn’t have to. Clemson returns a top-rated offense led by Heisman candidate Cade Klubnik, a loaded room of young receivers, and a veteran offensive line that might be one of the best in the country.
Oh — and they’re also bringing back 75% of their defense. Seventy-five percent.
The only truly eye-gouging loss? Phil Mafah. He brought balance to the ground game. But get this — Klubnik had just one fewer rushing touchdown than Mafah last season. So even that loss? Probably overblown.
If you’re looking for a veteran squad that’s dripping in talent, cohesion, and legit title juice, look no further than Clemson.
Arizona St. Sun Devils - 79%
I’ve been very surprised to see that ASU isn’t getting the love they fucking deserve after last year’s spectacular season. Yes, they lost Cam Skattebo. Yes, ASU’s run game will probably never be the same — fucking ever. But there’s still some NFL-level talent coming back to this team.
Sam Leavitt — projected first-rounder. His favorite target, Jordyn Tyson — another projected first-rounder. And if you remember anything about this team last year besides Skattebo, it was the defense. (If you remembered anything else, you simply don’t know ball.)
Well, 79% of that swarming defense returns for the 2025 season — the second most in all of college football. This team is going to be a real threat again this year. If they can figure out how to win football games without Skattebo, they’ll be fucking gross.
Not much has changed in Tempe, Arizona. And that’s a good thing.
Illinois Fighting Illini - 76%
This was a team I’ve already slobbered all over heading into the 2025 season — and I’m not backing off. Illinois is 100% my pick to be the sleeper that could fuck around and win the Big Ten.
The Illini return 76% of all production. And for a team that went 9–3 in the regular season and knocked off #15 South Carolina in their bowl game, I don’t see how that stat isn’t relevant.
75% of the defense is back — and that’s a unit Bret Bielema is constantly on these guys about. Last season, they gave up just 21.7 points per game — barely behind Michigan. No, they’re not the best defense in the Big Ten. But that same defense helped them to a 9–3 (okay, 10–3) season, and now they return damn near the whole crew.
I’m no mathematician, but you’d be blind not to connect the dots here.
The defense is back. And so is their star QB Luke Altmyer, who had a sneaky good season: over 2,700 yards, 22 touchdowns, just 6 picks. Now he’s a senior.
Look the fuck out, Big Ten. Illinois is coming — and they might just be better than 9–3 this year.
Texas Tech Red Raiders - 75%
What’s the one thing everyone keeps saying about Texas Tech this year?
That they’re pay to win. And honestly? They kind of are.
The Red Raiders are rolling into 2025 with one of the most expensive rosters in college football, hanging up there with the likes of Georgia, Bama, and Texas. But here’s the thing nobody wants to admit — money talks, and they’ve built a squad that could do more than just hang.
And what wins games? Defense, you absolute moron. (Or at least that’s what they say.)
Now, I’m not gonna sit here and pretend Tech had some elite unit last year. They were actually one of the worst defenses in the Big 12. But they kept themselves in games just enough to go 8–4 in the regular season, in what was probably the strongest Big 12 slate we’ve seen since realignment. But this team returns the highest production in all of college football at 81%.
Still, they had one thing going for them defensively — they could stop the damn run. And in a conference that’s about to get a little softer in 2025, that could matter a lot more.
On the other side of the ball? 68% of their offense returns, and that offense? It was #1 in the Big 12 in points per game last year.
So here’s the play: If this defense can level up from “liability” to “functional,” and the offense keeps cooking, Texas Tech could 100% make a run at the conference title.
They paid the price. Now it’s time to see if it buys them a trophy.
Texas A&M Aggies - 71%
Technically, Kennesaw State sits at No. 5 in returning production. But they’re not in my model — so suck me.
Instead, we’re going with a team that quietly finished 8–4 in the regular season last year — and yeah, I’d call that a win. Texas A&M put up a fight against future title contender Notre Dame in Week 1, beat #9 Missouri, beat #8 LSU, and hung around with #3 Texas and USC. That’s not fluky — that’s a team finally starting to deliver.
After seasons of being a punchline, this Aggie team is looking to plant their damn flag in the SEC.
Marcel Reed returns at QB. He took over after Weigman went down and handled business like John Wick. Reed put up 1,800+ passing yards, 15 touchdowns, and just 6 picks — and he did it in the SEC, not Conference USA. On the ground, he added 547 yards and 7 touchdowns, which is hella impressive for a guy who didn’t even start the season as QB1.
The offense brings back 70% of its production, which had them middle of the pack last year, but that’s plenty to work with. And the defense? 73% returning. Yeah, they were slightly below average, but they held their own in big moments. That kind of experience matters — especially when other SEC teams are about to fall back to Earth after portal-hyped runs and losing guys to the draft.
So what should we see from this team in 2025? We should — yeah, we fucking should — see damn near the same amount of firepower, but this time with more cohesion
and one of the most battle-tested rosters in the conference.
Don’t be shocked if Texas A&M ruins some dreams this year. The Aggies are cooking something down in College Station — and this time, it might actually taste good.
Comments